Thursday, April 23, 2015

Citizen Science Business Model: Bounty Hunter

At CitSci2015 I proposed a collection of business models that support, and benefit from, the work of citizen scientists and the reasons these are so important.  For the next few months I will be explaining each one in much more depth along with the current state of the market, obstacles to expanding connections to citizen science, and unexplored niches in each market.  These are needed to both help citizen scientists reap some rewards from the value they create, as well as convince firms to invest resources in developing tools to help the entire field grow.  To everyone's mutual benefit.  

Previous: Educator

This Week: Bounty Hunter
Next: Organizer (Coming Soon)

I've been thinking about citizen science bounties for a long time.  Back in 2011 I wrote an initial article talking about their definition and basic potential, hoping this would kick start some new thinking.  Much of that thinking is still valid and has been incorporated here.  But while people sent me some great ideas I have not seen it take off in the field yet.  Still not sure why.  Either way, there are still many great opportunities for both citizen scientists and for businesses wanting to work with them.

What I'm thinking of is very similar to, but distinct from, some of the innovation awards that groups like the Ansari XPrize and U.S. Government's site have offered.  Those are all focused on achieving a specific technical goal or development of a process.  And they are also quite large endeavors with precise rules on how the goal should be accomplished.  They may be somewhat loose rules, but they are still somewhat prescriptive in how to accomplish the goal.  

The bounties I'm thinking of are different by focusing on discovery, not creation or puzzle-solving.  They reward accomplishment of a specific tangible goal but are usually smaller in nature or more precise.  They also often involve more "brute-force" or trial-and-error searching as compared to innovative or creative puzzle solving. The example is an award to people who can find a particular rare bird, sight the first flower of a certain type to bud in spring, or discover an asteroid that will pass within a certain distance of Earth.  So it rewards a very specific discovery that is not a technical feat in and of itself, though building of tools to aid the discovery (such as building the proper telescopes of automating bird call identifications) may involve significant technical work. 

Historically people have used these types of bounty prizes to accomplish scientific goals but they haven't been popular recently.  Some of the more illustrative examples of bounty prizes I've seen are the Electronic Frontier Foundation Cooperative Computing Awards for finding the largest prime numbers.  The group offered prizes of up to $250,000 to the first person to discover a certain type of prime number.  There were no rules on how to do it, or what should be done with the number.  All the group required was someone to prove that the number was a Mersenne Prime and of the certain length.  This type of bounty-hunting is well-suited for distributed computing approaches that could crunch huge sets of numbers by brute force until the sought-after number was found.  And that's exactly what the GIMPS distributed computing project did to win the two most recent EFF bounties.

On a similar note, there is another concept that I also put into the bounties category.  These again focus on meeting a simple, tangible goal, but are used to reward progress or effort on a per-unit basis.  Again, nothing is being created here.  Instead we are rewarding someone who performs a scientific analysis task ten times, or collects three samples of a certain specimen, devotes 100 hours of computing time, identifies 200 uncharted Mars craters, or tracks the pollution in ten different streams.

Looking around I've seen a few examples of this so far but nothing major, and nothing active right now.  The closest I've found is the Cosmology@Home, a distributed computing project trying to model the current universe from various hypothetical starting points.  To encourage participation researchers offered a prize to the person whose computer model came closest to reality by a certain date; there was not a monetary prize but the winner would be mentioned in scientific articles about the work.  The most widely-known version may be's Mechanical Turk project.  Although not necessarily Citizen Science, it did provide bounties on a piecework basis for crowdsourced activities.  So people could be paid for writing ten web reviews, or transcribing a certain number of podcasts.  The private sector QMULUS Cloud Computing Platform also used this approach to encourage participation in an actual Citizen Science application.  Each month the company gave away gift certificates and free merchandise through a raffle to users of the system.  As a commercial entity they could afford to invest in these give-aways but there's no reason non-profit organizations couldn't do the same thing (ultimately I don't believe the QMULUS group was successful but that doesn't mean other firms can't be successful with similar ideas). There could also be many variations in the raffle entry for every work unit performed, or for per person using the system per month, or per participant in general.  There are many possibilities that could fit depending on the nature of the particular project.

Business Opportunities:
Much like "Solver: models, bounty models are great opportunities for companies interested in the Open Innovation benefits that come with asking the public for help on specific business problems.

One example is understanding protein folding...there are millions of potential ways a large molecule can be put together, but only one is the most stable.  So why not offer a reward to the person discovering the most stable shape using only knowledge of the molecular structure?  If the target chemicals are potential drugs or the cause of a disease, there is a lot of value in this work.  Researchers could provide the components of a key Malaria protein and offer $1,000 to the first person to identify it's shape.  Or provide the shape of an important AIDS protein and provide $5,000 to the person discovering a structure that will fit around it (thus neutralizing it's effect).

Bounty opportunities don't just involve one-of-a-kind discoveries. They can also be used to promote people finding more common items they wouldn't otherwise look for in an organized manner.  For example, a business operating in an environmentally sensitive area may want to encourage citizen scientists to survey the wildlife around a work site to show that environmental protections are working.  It can be expensive to constantly count the animals and plants in the area.  So they could pick some representative species (such as an apex predator) whose presence/lack of presence is correlated to how impacted to the area is, and then offer a bounty prize to whoever spots those animals near the firm's operations.  This rewards the citizen scientists doing the work, and since finding those species has economic value to the firm (by reducing their survey costs and protecting them from the costs of having caused pollution).  

Some people have started trying this model.  One example came up at CitSci 2015 in Tracy Lee's poster, "Unlikely Bedfellows: Industry, Conservation and Citizen Science in the Canadian Oil Sands".  A partnership put between a Canadian oil company (Cenovus) and the environmental non-profit Miistakis Institute created the Wild Watch program for tracking wildlife around some of their oil production facilities.  These facilities extract petroleum from the Canadian Oil Sands, a highly controversial activity due to its potential environmental impact.  Adding bounties as part of the reward mechanism encouraging citizen scientists to participate could potentially increase public participation greatly.

So these are my initial thoughts on bounties.  Right now there is a lot more promise with bounties than successful examples.  But hopefully we can help businesses and citizen scientists build them up together.


  1. thanks for sharing! get here free my singing monsters unlimited resources cheat to achive coins , gems and diamonds for upgrading, collect and breed new singing and dancing monsters and lot more fun free online.

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. Hi there, You’ve done a great job. I will definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am sure they’ll be benefited from this website….

  4. I needed to send you the tiny remark so as to say thank you over again over the amazing things you’ve shared at this time.

  5. Thanks for sharing excellent informations. Your site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you have on this site. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject.

  6. Welcomes to google terminal keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.
    google snake this was actually EARN TO DIE
    what i was looking for,and i am glad to came here! AGE OF WAR 2
    Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while HAPPY WHEELS
    I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! Slitherio
    Amazing insight you have on this, Slither io This article always blew me BIG FARM

  7. Thanks for sharing this wonderful article. Can some one tell me the Galaxy Note 7 date of release?

  8. The best space for your child to relax!: wingsio | slither io | abc

  9. Delighted to be here and to provide best info. Thanks
    High Class Call Girls in Jaipur

  10. Create your very own unique text smileys and lenny faces. Just click to copy !!!

  11. Very good. you are the winner. Do not forget update new information regularly. thank !
    - juegos friv gratis
    - Pokemon GO

  12. LG is about to launch its new flagship device, the LG G6 shortly.
    It has got awesome features and specs and is going to give tough competition to the Samsung galaxy series of smart phones.
    You will get all the information about the LG G6 from my blog. Just check it out.

  13. Find out your pet with pet GPS trackers.This is a multi function gadget.

  14. Bandar Terbesar Situs Togel Online Terpercaya. I was searching for something like that for quite a long time and at last I have found it here.CVS Prescription Refill

  15. This is one of the cult game now, a lot of people enjoy playing them . Also you can refer to the game :
    gold mine strike | pokemon go 2
    The game controls are shown just under . Movement mechanisms primarily include acceleration and tilting controls.
    stickman games | stick war 2 | animal jam 2

  16. want to know valentines day quotes for your lover,valentines day messages,valentines day images, just checkout my site Happy Valentines Day 2017

  17. want to know valentines day quotes for your lover,valentines day messages,valentines day images, just checkout my site Happy Valentines Day

  18. Best New Year 2017 Wishes images for wish someone special. View our blog to see new and unique images.

  19. This comment has been removed by the author.

  20. Thanks for sharing the awesome post and i will share it too.
    Norton Coupon Codes

  21. I like your all post. You have done really good work. Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot. I hope to have many more entries or so from you.

  22. Want to know about Veterans Day,which is a day to celebrate the great officers of the US army,just checkout my blog Happy Veterans Day and stay updated.

  23. To get best collection of wallpaper about Happy New Year 2017, View my blog Happy New Year 2017 Wallpapers

  24. Much gratitude to you for not floating perpetually just to fill the page. An obligation of appreciation is all together for sharing the information, continue doing exchange rates

  25. Latest collection of poems,quotes and pictures about Veterans Day 2016 Happy Veterans Day Quotes here.

  26. Wow, awesome post.Really thank you!

  27. New Year 2017 is just round the corner, and it is one of the most celebrated days of the year. You can checkout my blog Happy New Year 2017 Wishes for all other latest updates.

  28. Your blog is filled with unique good articles! I was impressed how well you express your thoughts and sharing your experiences.I never regretted any moment that came to your blog.
    hostgator black friday deals 2016

  29. Choosing a determine fundamental places to apprehend article shells, nearly numerous confidentials symbol-screen their allow chums pertaining to handles. Lecture Lib evidence be holy to gain varieds of streamer thorn customers who're merry beside the ramifications the street made processs too in scope they extra on putting warmhearted fresh petitions in supplement to bettering their agree qualities forward the.prepaid travel cards

  30. given article extremely helpful to my admin and pardon me permission to share articles herein may be useful :

    Cara melancarkan aliran darah tersumbat
    Cara menghilangkan jerawat punggung
    Khasiat apel hijau untuk menurunkan berat badan

  31. Halo bosku.. Bosan asik main judi online kalah-kalah aja? Buruan gabung bersama kami di W W W .C U M A P O K E R . C O M dijamin no ROBOT bosku.

    Kami menyediakan 7 jenis game dalam 1 user ID bosku
    -Bandar Poker
    -Capsa Susun
    -Sakong ( New Game yang sedang populer )

    Bonus yang diberikan kepada seluruh member kami yaitu
    -Bonus Turnover sebesar 0,5%
    -Bonus Referal sebesar 15%

    Kami menyediakan minimal deposit dan withdraw yang sangat rendah yakni Rp 15.000

    Kami juga menyediakan game yang tidak kalah populer bosku.

    Jadi, tunggu apa lagi segera bergabung bersama kami dan dapatkan hadiah ratusan juta.
    Yahoo :
    BBM : 2BE3DCA9
    No HP : +85585569262
    We chat : cumapoker

  32. Extremely Nice These are a portion of the solid choices, proposed for your utilization. Your blog posting in exceptionally intriguing for sharing. obat limpa bengkak

  33. This comment has been removed by the author.

  34. Spot on with this write-up, I truly believe that this amazing site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read through more, thanks for the information!

    Download Latest Information on Irish Patrick's day

  35. a given article is very interesting and very useful for me, thank you very much admin and pardon me permission to share the article here :

    Obat mioma uteri
    Obat bopeng
    Obat lambung bengkak

  36. Very useful post. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. Really its great article. can i refinance

  37. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped :

    Cara mengatasi haid tidak teratur
    Cara mengobati disentri
    Cara mengatasi stroke ringan

  38. thank you very useful information admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here may help

    Obat herbal slimming capsule
    Obat kelenjar tiroid
    Produk green world

  39. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped Obat infeksi ginjal

  40. imperial voyages is leading travel and tour operators in delhi we provide all affordable travel and tour packages at cheapest price we provide all affordable travel and tuor packages at low price. tour operators in delhi

  41. thanks for sharing best information, keep such update and share best ideas over to all and me so i very happy with this.




  42. thank you very useful information admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here may help Ciri ciri

    penyakit liver

  43. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped Cara mengatasi mata lelah dan berair

  44. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped Cara mengatasi mata lelah dan berair

  45. Thanks you for sharing your thoughts.I truly appreciate your post thank you once again.
    taruhan bola
    bandar bola
    bandar togel
    agen togel
    prediksi togel

  46. I think your website deserves to be the number one. hopefully it could be real. obat benjolan di tangan

  47. I regularly visit your site and find a lot of interesting information. Thank you and look forward to your page growing stronger.

  48. Tunjukkan Kemahiranmu Sebagai Penjudi Terbaik di Indonesia bersama kami, hanya di SiniDomino
    Dengan 1 User ID anda bisa bermain 7 permainan menarik di SiniDomino
    ★ Poker, ★ Kiu-Kiu, ★ Adu Q, ★ Capsa, ★ Bandar Poker, ★ Bandar Q, ★ Sakong
    Jangan ketinggalan bonus nya yah ;) :
    ♥ Minimal DEPOSIT & WITHDRAW Rp.20.000,-,
    ♥ Jackpot Jutaan hingga Ratusan Juta tiap hari nya

    Kunjungi Website nya disini :
    ★ www*sinidomino*com
    ★ www*maindisini*com
    ★ Hapus Tanda *

    Pin BBM : D61E3506
    Line : sinidomino
    Whatsapp : +85598249684

    Salam kemenangan dari kami ;)
    poker online

  49. Thank you for the information may be useful and successful for the future

  50. The structure of a very good blog, success continues to make the future


  51. nice info you got there, i found this site from my friend computer and good things this is a good site poker online


  52. nice info you got there, i found this site from my friend computer and good things this is a good site judi poker

  53. Thanks for the information you have provided, It is very helpful. Please improve again
    Resep Efektif Ramuan Herbal Untuk Mengatasi Insomnia

  54. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped Obat ginjal bocor herbal

  55. Exceptionally awesome web page. A great quantity of web journals I see nowadays don't usually give anything that I'm willing on, yet I'm certainly inspired by this one. Lately knowledgeable that I would post and let you know. independent Escorts in Udaipur

  56. Thanks for sharing this wonderful article the article is very interesting to read and may be useful for everything
    target black friday coupons

  57. The article you have shared here very good. This is really interesting information for me. Thanks for sharing!

  58. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here

    hopefully helped :

    Cara mengobati sesak nafas
    Cara mengatasi radang usus
    Khasiat kiwi

    untuk menurunkan darah tinggi

  59. This is very educating post, thanks for sharing with us.
    Tips Menang AduQ
    Tips Bermain AduQ



  62. Thank You for sharing such a great information!! Acer Customer Services

  63. Thanks for this informative post with us. It really helps us a lot.

    AOL Customer Service

  64. Nice post. Love it!!So inspiring.
    Keep it up :)

    Apple Tech support

  65. I like the above shared article very as it is very important to us. Thanks for sharing this article with us, keep updating us.
    Dell Customer Service

  66. Your blog posts are more interesting and impressive. I think there are many people like and visit it regularly, including me. I actually appreciate your wonderful blog and I will be sure to come back here again to see such great post.Yahoo Support

  67. The articles here are very useful. Keep posting and sharing.
    Lenovo Phone Number

  68. We provide solution regarding Ms office product. If you need any assistance regarding it than visit us.

  69. It's very informative Blog, it's more helpful to us thanks for sharing keep it up!!! Firefox Customer Tech Support

  70. Superb, what a web site it is! This webpage gives valuable facts to us, keep it up.
    iPhone customer support

  71. Nice blog post. Looking forward to sharing the new series with my potential brides. Chrome Customer Service

  72. It's very informative Blog, it's more helpful to us thanks for sharing keep it up!!! Opera Tech Support

  73. If girls like this gesture of you then continue with that touch her hand very lightly and continue with that. Hookup Apps

  74. hi guys, apa klian sudah mengenal BandarJudiQQ ? ketinggalan kalo kalian belum tau ~
    BandarJudiQQ adalah situs TERBAIK dan TERPERCAYA di INDONESIA.
    tidak hanya itu, BandarJudiQQ juga situs yang selalu memberikan bonus menarik buat para pemain baru maupun lama.
    cukup register dan memiliki 1 id kalian bisa menikmati 7 permainan.
    hanya dengan minimal deposit/windraw 15.000 saja kalian bisa menikmati keseruan bermain di BandarJudiQQ
    nikmati bonus Turnover 0.5% & bonus refferal hingga 20% (setiap hari senin setelah jam 12siang) dan banyak keuntungan bonus menanti anda.

    7 permainan BandarJudiQQ :
    Capsa Susun
    Bandar Poker

    BANK tersedia :

    buat para pemain BandarJudiQQ tidak hanya bermain di komputer tetapi kalian bisa menikmati bermain melalui gadget/smartphone.
    keseruan bermain dimana dan kapan saja sesama player TANPA BOT .
    jika kalian mengalami kendala segera hubungi CustumerService(CS) kami siap membantu melayani anda 24jam.
    -PIN BBM : 336057ED
    -SKYPE :
    -TWITTER :
    -YAHOO :
    -PHONE : +855962054695


  75. Hello, I take a job out from the gurgaon associates Spa for dedication, particular on the globally web alternatives along with appropriate take excellent excellent appropriate excellent my men. thanks Independent Escorts in Dwarka, Dwarka Escorts Service, Female Escorts in Dwarka | Independent Escorts in Dwarka, Dwarka Escorts Service, Female Escorts in Dwarka, Escorts in Dwarka

  76. You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site. Windows 10 Help and Support

  77. I genuinely appreciate your piece of work, Great post BandarQ

  78. interesting articles and this is my first first reading a very interesting article thanks for this article that fits with the theme news.
    agen poker online terbaik indonesia

  79. Your blog is really an inspiration to many. I’ll be looking forward for more of your posts. Keep it up!

  80. This is very usefull information
    Sakong Online

    Thank you information that you have brought, very interesting, please visit our website
    Agen BandarQ
    BandarQQ Online
    Agen Sakong Online

  81. please check out the web-sites we comply with, including this a single, because it represents our picks from the web Domino QQ Online

  82. yes..I like the basic concepts behind Second Life but it seems incredibly outdated and when I played it was intensely non-intuitive / user friendly to an extent that made EVE look like a game for toddlers. thanks from:
    Agen Togel
    Bandar Togel
    Togel Online
    Bandar Togel Online
    Keluaran Togel
    Bandar Togel Terpercaya
    Togel Singapore
    Togel Hongkong
    Togel Sydney

  83. check our website to know the reviews of assignment writing service providers.
    Domino QQ Terpercaya
    Poker Online Terpercaya

  84. I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job!
    obat ginjal bengkak
    obat sakit pinggang
    obat susah kencing

  85. Really appreciate you sharing this article post.Much thanks again. Awesome
    agen semua judi
    Bandar Poker Terpercaya

  86. This is really very nice blog and so informative, It give us lots of interest and pleasure.
    Agen Poker

    Nice post, Thanks a lot of for share the informative and useful blog.
    Daftar BandarQ