Monday, February 18, 2013

Why Do the Longest Films Win the Best Editing Oscar? A Citizen Science Investigation

Citizen science is an amazing hobby.  You can learn about the natural world, meet fascinating people, and help make the world a better place.  But it also gives you very powerful tools.  Tools that can be used in many wonderful areas life.  Such as discovering that the longest film nominated each year for the Best Film Editing Oscar is more than twice times as likely to win as any other films, and that the two longest nominated films combine to win 2/3 of the time.

Obviously today's post is a little different than others.  Instead of gauging water quality or tracking hurricanes, I'm looking at the Academy Awards.  But this issue has nagged at me ever since 15-year old OpenScientist watched the three-hour long film "Dances with Wolves" win the award.  While I enjoyed the movie in general, it was very long and meandering with large stretches containing lots of scenery and very little dialogue.  It didn't even seem like there were many cuts in the film; instead it was filled with long single-take shots that never even needed an editor.  Could it be that Oscar voters didn't understand editing at all, and just felt that long was equal to good?  Today that 15-year old boy finds out.

It turns out to be a relatively simple analysis.  I pulled the names of all Best Editing nominees for the last 35 years from Wikipedia, and pulled their running times as listed by the Internet Movie Database (IMDB).  I then ranked each film by it's length relative to the other nominated films (e.g., the longest film each year earns a "1", the shortest earns a "5") and also listed which of the films actually won that year.  A spreadsheet with all that data is available publicly here.

Before we see the results, why pick the last 35 years?  Why not 20 or 50?  Well, for starters I wanted a meaningful population of films in the modern era.  Editing technology and film styles have changed over the years so there needed be some consistency.  I also needed enough data points to make any conclusion scientifically reliable.  But most important of all is that 35 years ago Star Wars won for Best Editing.  The nerd in me just had to use that as my starting point.

Now back to the research.  Totaling up all the wins and rankings, we find the longest-running nominated picture each year wins Best Editing a whopping 44% of the time.  That's three times more likely than any of the three shortest films nominated each year, and even twice the rate of the second-longest running film.  Clearly being longer is powerful.

Another way to look at the results is that the two longest-running films take home an Oscar 66 percent of the time (two times out of three!).  But the most powerful way of looking at this is by charting the wins by relative film length, as shown below:

Image Courtesy: OpenScientist

Not only is being longest a powerful predictor of wining, but there is a clear connection between running time and likelihood of winning.  At every step the longer a film is compared with it's competitors, the more likely it is to win.

Why is this?  Personally, I think it's because nobody understands what good film editing is.  Even watching this clip featured on the Oscar web site doesn't really help us understand it.  The best they say is good editing can be distinguished when the movie works (you aren't pulled out of the film), the character relationships make sense, and that performances are top-notch.  Barely mentioned are things like the use of pacing to highlight the emotions of scenes, creating tension through cuts, or choosing to focus on a character's actions vs. focusing on the reactions of others around that character.  Those are much more essential but even the experts have trouble defining them.

Which brings us to the key voters just don't understand what they are voting on.  Yet under the Academy rules (available here), voting is open to all Academy members.  Many are actors, actresses, make-up artists, costume designers, etc., who have not spent any time behind a camera or understanding the editing process.  They know good films, but really aren't experts outside their own specialties  This is different than other technical categories requiring only specialists in those fields.  There also is no rule requiring voters to have even seen the whole film. 

All this adds up to voters voting on something they have no understanding of and may not have even seen.  So what do they do?  They vote for the longest movie. 

To me, editing is improving by cutting. An editors job should be boiling down a film to it's bare elements (editing) and removing unnecessary camera shots or performances.  But when the Academy rewards editors unable to do that, and encourages longer films with few cuts, it is just asking for overly long films told less effectively and less powerfully.

All this leads to  a final question...who will win Best Film Editing for 2012?  According to the film's running length, it should be Zero Dark Thirty (clocking in at 157 minutes), followed by Lincoln (150 minutes), Life of Pi (127 minutes), Silver Linings Playbook (122 minutes) and Argo (120 minutes). 

And that's without even watching the films.

Congratulations to the Argo team and their Best Editing Oscar.  Not only did they win the adulation of fans, but they overcame the "Longest Film Curse" and actually won with this year's shortest film. 

I stand by the facts laid out above showing a clear preponderance of voters choosing longer films.  But statistics are not destiny, and sometimes films defy the odds.  Over time I still expect the longer films will win.  But only time will tell.


  1. Dear friends,
    An important variable is that there are much more good long films them bad long films. The reasons are two: 1) bad/new/risky directors/producers do not get budget to do a 3 hours film; and 2) when someone does get it and the result is dubious, it is striped to regular 90 min length to stand some chance of success (at least at TV, Airplane, DVD).

  2. Wow! I’m from Malaysia, an English teacher gonna be. Now, I know that my goal readers are my students in the past. Custom essay writing online I’d like to mark like this too attractive event and real hard work to make an enormous article. Thank you for the suggestions, I really enjoyed reading this. It is so much inspiring.

  3. may be useful for all, helpful article once and pardon me permission to share also here :

    Cara mengatasi sesak nafas
    Obat hepatitis b
    Cara menyembuhkan flek paru paru

  4. Mari gabung bersama kami di Domino Halo
    * Bonus Referal 20%
    * Bonus T.O mingguan sebesar 0.5%
    * Minimal deposit RP.20.000
    * Jackpot tercepat

    DOMINOHALO - Agen Poker Terpercaya | Texas Poker | Poker Online | DominoQQ Online | BandarQ Online | Agen Poker Terpercaya Se-Indonesia


  5. شركة نقل عفش بالرياض وجدة والدمام والخبر والجبيل اولقطيف والاحساء والرياض وجدة ومكة المدينة المنورة والخرج والطائف وخميس مشيط وبجدة افضل شركة نقل عفش بجدة نعرضها مجموعة الفا لنقل العفش بمكة والخرج والقصيم والطائف وتبوك وخميس مشيط ونجران وجيزان وبريدة والمدينة المنورة وينبع افضل شركات نقل الاثاث بالجبيل والطائف وخميس مشيط وبريدة وعنيزو وابها ونجران المدينة وينبع تبوك والقصيم الخرج حفر الباطن والظهران
    شركة نقل عفش بجدة
    شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
    شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض
    شركة نقل عفش بالدمام

  6. Fajartoto is the Bandar Togel Terpercaya, Online Togel Agent, Trusted Online Togel & Situs Casino Online that has been proven to be a trusted place to place online lottery betting numbers for online lottery lovers and Judi Casino Online. Fajartoto as the Trusted Online Bandar Togel, Online Togel Agent and Trusted Togel Site that provides 9 official online lottery markets such as SGP pools, lottery pools, lottery pools, canadia pools, togel saigon pools, Siamese pools, khmer pools , lottery israel pools and toto macanese 4D pools. Please come to visit my website Syair Togel Hongkong and Prediksi Togel Hongkong

  7. So then when I'm finished
    I'm all 'bout my business and ready to save the world
    I'm taking my misery
    Make it my bitch; can't be everyone's favorite girl

    Obat Penyakit Kusta
    Obat Penebalan Dinding Rahim
    Obat Penurun Kreatinin
    Obat Pembersih Usus
    Cara Mengatasi Protein Dalam Urine

  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

  9. I enjoy reading it. I fundamental to learn more on this subject.. Thanks for the sake theme this marvellous post.. Anyway, I am gonna subscribe to your silage and I wish you post again soon. Find out today's Celebrity birthdays and discover who shares your birthday. We make it simple and entertaining to learn about celebrities.


  10. The girls here with us would never call you once your booking is over. This is one of the reasons why we here at the house ofRussian Escorts in Gurgaon have earned ourselves a great reputation and a goodwill that is surely unmatchable. Check our other Services...
    Call Girls in Gurgaon
    Escorts Service in Gurgaon
    Russian Call Girls in Gurgaon
    Russian Escorts in Gurgaon
    Russian Escorts in Gurgaon
    Russian Call Girls in Gurgaon

  11. Get all the latest updates and get the items same as breeze gazebo at lowest price items in Auckland Newzealand. All the items are easily availalble which you will be get online in a single click.

  12. An interesting discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  13. You have a great blog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my blog?

    Click Here
    Visit Web

  14. I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.
    Click Here

  15. They are searching on the Matriculation for their TNBSE SSLC 10th Previous Question Papers 2023 on online mode. So, here on this article, we are informing to all students that the Tamil Nadu Board will Tamil Nadu SSLC Important Question Paper 2023 publish the TNDGE Matric Exam 10th Previous Question Papers 2023 TN SSLC 10th Previous Question Papers 2023 Download Now Download Tamil Nadu 10th Latest Question Papers 2023