Saturday, May 7, 2016

Inclusion and the 2017 Citizen Science Association Conference

Photo Courtesy: James Willamor
It seems like not too long ago since we all met in San Jose for the last Citizen Science conference.  But time quickly moves on and planning is actively underway for the next conference to be held next February, 2017.  CitSci 2017 promises to be full of useful information and interesting people, but there are many obstacles to overcome first.  Including politics.

Sadly, completely outside of anyone's control from our field, the State of North Carolina recently passed HB2, the so-called "Bathroom Bill" requiring people to only use the bathrooms assigned to their biological sex, and eliminating many legal protections for lesbian, gay, and transgender people.  To quote the CitSci 2017 planners:

The bill flies in the face of the principles on which we are building this association, those of supporting inclusion, diversity, and personal freedom. It also throws a huge monkey wrench into planning a conference where everyone feels safe and welcome. The legislation and ensuing counter-actions in protest both compromise the opportunity for this conference to be safe and inclusive, goals that we strongly value, as do our host partners.

As a private citizen living outside of North Carolina, this bill troubles me with its attempts to not only stigmatize a vulnerable transgender population, but to actively tell local governments that it is illegal to protect entire swaths of people.  This is a highly dangerous proposition and one I personally can't support.  It certainly makes me not want to spend money in that State.  But should we sacrifice the many good things that can come out of the conference because of the law?  Are we hurting our many allies in North Carolina who don't support the law?  Can we be an agent of change through our examples of openness and inclusion?  These are no longer hypotheticals but real questions with serious consequences (on both sides).

Everyone is wrestling with this question, including the conference planners.  They take their jobs seriously and seem to be struggling with a course of action.  But they don't need to decide alone.  They have set up a survey for all members (and other potential conference goers) to let their own voices be heard.  Let the association know whether you are planning to attend, whether the NC law prevents you from attending (either legally or ethically), whether you'd like to see the conference moved, and any alternative solutions to the problem.  While I don't think it is binding they want to hear from us all, and I applaud them for taking this step.  So please help them by reading their detailed concerns here and taking the survey.  Decisions must be made soon so please provide your thoughts as soon as possible.  We all appreciate it.

Where do I stand?

In my humble opinion, this law is based on the assumption that allowing transgender people into the bathroom of their choosing will threaten the safety of others.  But there is no evidence that this is the case, and as far as I've seen, there have been NO reported cases of transgender individuals attacking or otherwise harassing people in the bathroom.  As a citizen science organization I believe we should hold tightly to relying on facts and honest inquiry as the basis for making laws, and this bill represents neither of those.  It comes only from mean-spiritedness (by some) and fear (by others).  But not from any real threat.  Unfortunately the logic argument has already been lost, so I can't see how keeping the conference in the State will change any hearts of minds; that ship has already sailed.  So that is why I personally voted that we move the conference.  Even if it costs a bit more, or involves extra hassle, it is an important step and one that will have more impact than staying and attempting to lead by example.  This type of ecoomic pressure has worked for other State laws and it is (sadly) time we do the same.

But what's your opinion?  Please let the association know so that whatever the decision, we can start acting to help the situation and people stuck in it.


  1. Hi author, you have pointed out a very crucial and sensitive real issue here. I honestly agree with you opinion about this bill. It not only pose discrimination but also tells the people that it is ok to practice such prejudice to the transgender and gay community and more so, a waster of money and time of the legislative. You are writing a wonderful topic here. Are you looking for writers for hire coz if so, i know people whom i could recommend you. I a know a few who are very good as well.

  2. Thank you for sharing the post.
    Even when you are quite good at using internet or email, you may have problems with it. Some problems are quite common and you can solve it (forgot password, forgot username...) but sometimes, because of the high secure policy of Google, proxy problems... you may cannot sign in your email. If you cannot solve it yourself, Gmail sign in will be a helpful choice.

  3. Winter is the season of love definitely, definitely so. Because the weather does not have to make several of romantic things, telling each other things so sweet as this cold season. Winter that it is easy to fall in love than
    b612 , run , geometry dash , download snapchat , musicas download

  4. Article is deeply and bring a lot of information, thank you for your contribution, very dear how to get help in windows 10

  5. I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article.

  6. I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. I like play game five nights at freddy’s 4, game word cookies game , game word cookies answers , hotmail sign in and hotmail login, and u? I hope people visit my website.

  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

  8. If you face any kind of trouble during movies downloading and you want to see latest movies in HD format then you need an app like Showbox.
    Nowadays this app is getting much popular because of its attractive and trendy
    ShowBox for PC

  9. Are They Related? Dr Mark Hyman can be followed on a number of the most popular social networks, click on any of the links below to keep up to date! There haven't been a lot of studies done on this herb, so many of the purported benefits are more a matter of herbalist tradition than modern science. Bacopa is an excellent choice if you have problems with memory, learning and concentration brought on by stress. Most Ginkgo biloba benefits have stood the test of time in both traditional Chinese medicine and as a prescription medication in Europe. And lastly, for those diagnosed with dementia or Alzheimer's, ginkgo shows great promise for improving memory and day-to-day quality of life. And, of course, you may decide that its long history of traditional use outweighs the latest scientific findings.>>>

  10. Facing problem while getting a more robust penile erection, sometimes you might be losing in the middle section of a hobby and your partner remains unsatisfied. This is the sign of ED which is often treated with generic viagra.

  11. If you have a Testoultra project planned, maybe you need to consult a Testoultra Male Enhancement pro. I must disagree, but your Testoultra basically clarifies this to you. I may be may be pleased with this. Regardless, I'm not going to name any names although it would apply to this situation.
    Do you recognize that timeless BeeGees track? That was actual proof. When comes down to it I would face that as soon as they possibly can. Time is a healer. This is a public way to getting into this. In spite of this, this is time to tell you precisely why Testoultra is like this. I'd like to make you a promise. There is no question regarding that, organizations liked Fitness. Testoultra is yet another type of Testoultra Male Enhancement.>>